How to Stop Dog Play From Turning Into a Fight

When two dogs are playing together, it's important to recognise when things are starting to get a little too intense. There are several ways we can help prevent play from escalating into a fight. Here's one technique I regularly use, and why it works so well.

Why Play Can Turn Into a Fight

When the energy between two dogs starts to build, one dog will often try to communicate that they've had enough and want the play to stop.

These communications are usually quite subtle. They might be small changes in body language or other little signals that are easy to miss. If the other dog doesn't recognise or respond to these cues, the first dog may feel the need to escalate their communication by giving a much stronger correction. Unfortunately, this is where things can turn into a fight.

This is where we, as humans, need to step in.

Our job is to recognise these early signs before things escalate and advocate for the dog that needs our help. Sometimes a dog simply isn't confident or capable of advocating for themselves, so we need to do it on their behalf.

Other times, a dog may struggle to communicate appropriately. They might come on too strong, or their communication may not be clear enough for the other dog to understand. In these situations, we can step in and help guide them, too.

There's another important factor to consider: energy.

Dogs can become increasingly excited during play, and sometimes the activity itself isn't enough to bring that excitement back down. When their energy continues to build without an opportunity to settle, they may find other ways to release it. Unfortunately, a fight can become one of those outlets simply because it creates an even higher level of activity and intensity.

The Solution: Ask Both Dogs to Lie Down

One simple but effective technique I use to help prevent play from escalating is to interrupt it before the energy gets too high and ask both dogs to lie down.

Once they're down, I wait until both dogs are genuinely relaxed and calm before allowing play to resume.

Depending on the dogs and how excited they've become, this process may need to be repeated several times throughout the play session.

The goal isn't to stop them from having fun. It's to give them an opportunity to reset, bring their excitement levels down and return to play in a calmer state.

What Am I Looking For?

When I ask the dogs to lie down, I'm not simply looking for them to be in a down position. I'm looking for a relaxed body and, just as importantly, a relaxed mind.

Their bodies should look comfortable rather than tense or ready to spring back into action. Their overall body language should indicate that they're settling, rather than simply waiting for the next opportunity to play.

Here's a simple test I like to use:

Once both dogs are lying down, try moving around or looking in different directions. Can you do this without the dogs immediately trying to get back up?

If they pop straight back up every time you move, they're likely still anticipating what's coming next rather than genuinely relaxing.

I want to see dogs that can remain settled even when there's movement around them. This helps me recognise that their excitement has come down and they're in a much calmer state of mind.

Once both dogs are genuinely relaxed, you can allow them to get back up and resume playing.

Repeat the process as often as needed.

Remember: The aim isn't to take the fun out of play. It's to help dogs regulate their excitement, recognise when they need a break and enjoy playing together without things getting out of hand.

Next
Next

Why Are You Patting Your Dog?